Just got notice from my insurance company (auto only) that they are going to be ordering insurance loss history reports and motor vehicle reports. They will help determine our eligibility for insurance and the price we may be charged.
All well and good. But here’s the kicker, the part I don’t get. They also say that they may order additional consumer reports that include our credit info. They may use a credit-based insurance score based on that info. And they may use a 3rd party to develop our credit-based insurance score.
Is this normal? Do many companies do this? Is this something that anyone else is outraged about, and is anyone fighting this?
I don’t have much cause for concern really, but I don’t get what one thing has to do with the other. You could explain that to me too!
If it matters, this is American Family Insurance.
Does State Farm do this?
I’m in Milwaukee Wisconsin.
Any respectable insurance company uses credit as a risk indicator, and with good reason.
I saw some good points mentioned, but here’s a few things that haven’t been mentioned.
1. Credit is used to decrease rates, not increase them. If your credit stinks, then you don’t get the decrease. The perfect example of this is in states where credit is not allowed. Across the board all rates in the state went up, since a rating factor was removed, and the insurer assumed everyone has bad credit then.
There is statistically a direct correllation between poor credit and poor driving history and high risk. This means that more responsible people keep their finances in order and also tend to drive safer. Some would argue that this is a poor tax, however, I have seen many low income families with high credit scores and excellent driving histories, just as I have seen many rich families with terrible credit and driving histories.
2. Regarding the zip code thing, this is 100% based on the claims ratios in a given territory, also used to decrease the rates in low risk areas. Don’t believe me, go to California where zip code is no longer a factor, and people across the state pay the same high rates as the people in LA who have percentagewise a much higher risk for claims.
3. Credit scoring is nothing new in insurance, and is a fact of life. It is one of many factors that are used to contribue to the rate. Per insurance law, a company may not unfairly discriminate. This means that they may fairly discriminate for factors such as driving history, claims, age, gender, zip code, credit, and others. However, they may not do so based on skin color, religion, etc…
4. State Farm does use credit, as does Farmers, Geico, Progressive, Nationwide, Allstate, and every other company worth using as your carrier.